Still on FiM in 2024 and want a review or have a review to share? Then you are in the right place.
If requesting: great! Put the story in the 'pending review' folder. Message a reviewer first for best results. Once the review is complete, move the story to the relevant folder.
If sharing a review: great! Put it below. Give the author, title, link and whether positive or negative. If you are not the author of the review, then do not copy/paste the full review without consent.
If sharing a reviewed story: put the story in either the positive or negative reviews folder, but you MUST post the corresponding review in the comments.
If wanting to review: I <3 you! Check the pending folders.
Info:
- You can ask for reviews either of your own work or the work of another
- When contacting reviewers, try to get a sense of what they want to read/review. My preferences are here.
Meta:
Banner is AI
REVIEW [NSFW] Soft and Pink - semillon (Random Recommendations in <50 words #14)
Review by me
Verdict: recommend
A Passing Comet - Admiral Producer (Random Recommendations in <50 words #13)
Verdict: recommend
Reviewer: me
Rairity learns math - Gavier
Verdict - recommend
Reviewer: me
Finding a Haven - SockPuppet (Random Recommendations in <50 words #11)
Verdict: recommend
Reviewer: me
Wishing Lantern by Quoterific (Random Recommendations in <50 words #10)
Verdict: recommend.
Reviewed by: me
Sun Never Sets
https://www.fimfiction.net/blog/1039196/sun-never-sets-by-crownofdissonance-recommendation-style-short-review-for-fics-i-would-recommend-but-for-flaws-with-the-format-that-can-be-sorted-with-editing
Positive but not yet recommending due to some editing issues
Reviewed by me
Lateral Movement
Verdict: positive but could not recommend due to editing - but really very good! (ie go read it!)
Reviewer: me
Love is Magic by ales_horses (Recommendation-style short-review - for fics I would recommend, but for flaws with the format that can be sorted with editing)
Reviewed by me.
Verdict: positive but not yet recommended as needs edit
The Story of Everfree - a Narrative Chronicle
https://www.fimfiction.net/blog/1039024/short-review-violence-the-story-of-everfree-a-narrative-chronicle-recon777-random-recommendations-in-50-words-9
Reviewed by me (first 4K words)
Verdict: recomment
Holes by semillon (Random Recommendations in <50 words #8)
Reviewed by: me
Verdict: recommend
Rarity learns Math by Gavier
Review by me.
Verdict: positive, but not quite recommended..
THE COST TO KNOW EVERYTHING by
Thunder--Dash
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/493070/the-cost-to-know-everything
Review by me, result shared by PM.
REVIEW [NSFW!] Uncorinthian BY Petrichord (Random Recommendations in <50 words #7)
[NSFW]
Reviewed by me.
Verdict: recommend
DEEP-DIVE REVIEW! We Are the Everfree - Everfree's Trees are not like other trees, by Loganberry 'the Wordsmith' (>1K Word Deep-Dives and Author Recommendations #1)
https://www.fimfiction.net/blog/1038351/deep-dive-review-we-are-the-everfree-everfrees-trees-are-not-like-other-trees-by-loganberry-1k-word-deep-dives-and-author-recommendations-1
Reviewed by me.
Verdict: recommend
REVIEW! The Anatomy of Aesthetics ~ History recalls Flaire d'Mare as the eminent fashion designer ~ by AltruistArtist (Random Recommendations in <50 words #6)
HERE
Reviewed by me.
Verdict: recommend
REVIEW: On the Wrong Track - The Equestrian Railways network is remarkable. That's the problem by Loganberry. (Random Recommendations in <50 words #5)
Review by me.
Verdict: recommend.
Team Superstars: Winds of Change - Lulamoon-Crystal
Review shared by PM.
It Doesn't Matter Now - The End of All There Ever Was is due – but Pinkie Pie needs to finish something first by Loganberry (Random Recommendations in <50 words #4)
Reviewed by me.
Verdict: recommend.
Review by Azure Drache
Verdict: positive overall, but not yet recommended.
We Are the Everfree - Everfree's Trees are not like other trees, by Loganberry (Random Recommendations in <50 words #3) ·
Reviewed by me
Verdict: recommend