• Member Since 14th Feb, 2012
  • offline last seen 14 hours ago

horizon


Not a changeling.

More Blog Posts309

Oct
25th
2012

Unsolicited writing tool recommendation · 7:22pm Oct 25th, 2012

Despite working in the tech industry for my day job, I've never been very high-tech with my fanfic tools. All you need for a story is the ability to type in text, right? A few basic formatting commands are nice (bold and italics), as well as the ability to synchronize your story between different computers so you can work on it no matter where you are (Dropbox is simple and robust for that). I've never needed or wanted anything more fancy.

All that has changed.

I just picked up a copy of Scrivener. I've barely started using it and I'm blown away. All of the tools I never even knew I needed are right there at my fingertips.

An hour ago, Haylander: Origins was spread out across three text files and a Google Doc spreadsheet:

- The story itself
- My language notes (Old English and Early Modern English reference, translations, and links)
- A random notes file: for character bios, cut-but-awesome dialogue, to-dos, etc
- An outline by scene

It's now in a single project, subdivided by chapter and then by scene, with each scene color-coded with its current writing status. Notes can attach to specific sections of the story or to the story as a whole, and open up in a sidebar while you're working on the relevant section; the character bios and language notes are within the project in separate research folders by topic. I can move between all of the different elements -- story, research, whatever -- with a click, and open them up side-by-side or in pop-out windows if I need brief access to something.

My outline spreadsheet is now completely unnecessary, because it's wholly integrated. Each chapter/scene (even the ones I haven't written yet) has a little summary, and with a single click I can go into an "index-card" view or outline view that shows me the scene-by-scene flow:

And all my freaking out over which scenes go in which order? Flipping the order of things around is as simple as a drag and drop.

Scrivener also tracks word-counts in real time; lets you set and meet word-count goals for specific sections or chapters; and has a distraction-free mode that blanks out the rest of your screen so you are looking at nothing but your words. Basically, every single thing that I've ever done to make my writing easier is built-in, and the tools that I'm using are just a tiny subset of its options; they swiss-army-knife it to work with a wide variety of writing styles, so that you can sit down with it as a simple text editor and then start adding in the features that are useful to you. My wife's about to start using it to type up a screenplay, which simply involves opening up a different template type and turning on some of the options I'm ignoring; it handles all of that formatting natively.

Still not sold? It is the only writing program I've yet found that lets you copy formatted text in BBCode format, so that you can copy and paste it directly into FIMFiction when you're done, 100% ready to go, without needing to worry about messy imports or meticulously re-formatting all the emphasized bits.

Scrivener's available as a time-limited free demo, but is well worth the $45.00 fee.


UPDATE:

A month later, Scrivener essentially paid for itself.

I was working back and forth between a few different computers (its license is remarkably generous about that) on the same story, synchronizing the story file into my Dropbox account every time I switched (this lets me easily toss edits in from work, or write on my laptop, when the creative bug strikes and I'm not at my main computer). But my network hiccuped, and somehow I opened up an old version of the file before my laptop finished syncing the Dropbox folder. I made a few edits and saved my changes ... and then, a few minutes later, realized that two days' worth of typing was missing. Dropbox, helpful little beast that it was, updated every one of my computers with the truncated version of the story file, and it doesn't have a history function. I lost several thousand words.

Except I didn't -- because Scrivener is even more awesome than it has any right to be.

Not only does Scrivener autosave every few seconds, as a backup against forgot-to-Ctrl-S syndrome ...

Not only does Scrivener have a "snapshot" feature that lets you save archived versions of a chapter for quick reference and reversion (which I hadn't started using yet) ...

But Scrivener, without any configuration and without even asking, automatically writes a totally separate backup of your story every time it closes the file. Since the main story file was in Dropbox but the backups weren't, I was able to go to the computer I did the lost writing on, grab the last-good backup from the backups folder, open it up, and copy and paste everything I lost back into the story.

Never mind that it saved me about six hours of work (even at minimum wage that pays for the program). It probably saved the story I was writing. In the past, I literally have given up on a story after losing several thousand words of it. Trying to recreate something I finished and liked, but lost, is the most heartbreaking thing in the world.


Further recommendations: GhostOfHeraclitus was dubious until he gave it a try and now swears by it too.

Report horizon · 1,873 views ·
Comments ( 16 )

Ah, but can you pass the hours trying to highlight things, adding comments, and losing documents into disorganized Gdoc archives?
I thought not!

I'm not a writer, but I am a programmer, so I know the value of a good editing tool. This actually looks pretty neat.

I think you've sold me on a copy of Scrivener. I'm keeping this page open; I'll follow the link eventually.

447383 It does actually have a highlighting feature and built-in comments (similar to the notes feature I mentioned) -- as well as letting you change text colors when you're revising (and flattening the text back to black once you're satisfied). Losing documents into GDoc archives ... hmm. That one's a little harder. :raritywink:

I do have to add that I'll continue to use GDocs for prereading, only because it doesn't require everyone to be using the same software. But it's easy enough to copy and paste directly there from Scriv once I finish writing.

447407 It was tempting to say "Scrivener! It's a word processing IDE!" but I didn't know how many of my readers would understand.

... of course, if you think of it that way, what's most amazing is why I wasn't desperately searching for it (or something like it) before now.

447699 Yay! It'll be most useful for longer stories, or stories where the outline/research integration are positive features (that's what made it worth the purchase price for me), but even if you use it for nothing beyond the distraction-free mode and in-line wordcount, it's still a handy thing.

447829

The phrase "Scrivener! It's a word processing IDE!" might also have successfully sold me on it, actually, with very little elaboration. I understand what that means, and I would trust you to have judged rightly. A similar reason resulted in my acquisition of the much more expensive Dramatica. Dramatica, as it turns out, has never assisted me in any accomplishment... but at least it's been fun! :trollestia:

Benman
Site Blogger

Sweet Celestia this is the greatest thing since I discovered copy/paste

472899 I KNOW!!! :rainbowkiss:

So.

Scrivener.

Still worth it?

2163032
Still worth it. :twilightsmile:

2163628
It's difficult for me to make a purchase that sounds like I don't need it, and usually that's the end of it, except for all these I DIDN'T THINK I NEEDED IT EITHER BUT I WAS SO WRONG comments.

Knowing me, also, if the learning curve is anything more drastic than a gentle incline I will end up just not using half the features anyway because I am lazy like that. Ay, well, may be time to see what the freebie trial is all about. Thanks for your time.

2164019 2165022
From a quick glance at yWriter it looks like it's designed to serve a lot of the same needs (though Scrivener does have the benefit of being cross-platform, and since I'm a Mac guy that's a big deal). For FIMFiction usage, the BBCode export alone may be worth the price of admission. I've also started to lean very heavily on the "snapshot" feature — Scrivener lets you freeze the current version of a chapter for rollback (and it looks like yW does something similar) — that lets me give my brain permission to rip the innards out of a chapter without that existential terror of maybe destroying a good idea and turning it irreplaceably into something worse.

But, yeah. Give one or the other a shot, with the free software or the generous freebie period. Scrivener has an awesome built-in tutorial you can spend an afternoon wandering through, or you can watch a ten-minute video with the basics and be ready to jump right in.

QuollWriter seems to have many of these desirable functions as well, since we're tossing out recommendations. It takes some getting used to, but the effort has been well worth it.

Pardon the late game intrusion.

2360410
Oh, no worries; clearly people are still reading this post, so links to other helpful software are still useful. :twilightsmile:

2360498 What sort of nutcase would waste his time reading 2-year-old posts? :rainbowhuh:

Still worth it?

2526251
Yes, for the same reasons. Snapshots/revision control, automated backups, and the always-at-my-fingertips BBCode export. A little frustrated that it doesn't support iOS, but none of the writing tools I would use in its place do, either; and I've had some problems syncing between computers with it, but that's not Scrivener's fault, that's Dropbox's.

:twilightsmile:

Login or register to comment