Nine Elements Group 12 members · 10 stories
Comments ( 76 )
  • Viewing 51 - 100 of 76

7931097
Cool. So, when and how did Susan learn guitar? Was it before the first movie or did she learn it between the first movie and Rainbow Rocks as a means of dealing with her stress and self-loathing after the Fall Formal and being a social pariah in the school?

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7932193
She learned before the first movie.

7932212
So, then did Pony Sunset already know Susan can play guitar? And if so, did she ever try to bring it up to the HuMane 5 at any point or probably didn't tell them (given they weren't including her in the band until the climax of Rainbow Rocks)?

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7932241
Sunset learned from Susan and played with the HuMane 5 before the first movie. Roxy suggested that Sunset play with them for old time’s sake. Before leaving for Equestria, Roxy asked Sunset if she could come play music with them again sometime when she’s not busy. However, Sunset suggests letting Susan take her spot. When Susan demonstrates her skills, the Rainbooms are amazed by how similar they are to Sunset’s, to which Susan responds, “Who do you think taught her to play like that in the first place?”

So in terms of where the specials and movies are gonna be placed in this version, we know the first movie is obviously between seasons 3 and 4, Rainbow Rocks is between seasons 4 and 5, and Friendship Games happens at the same time as The Cutie ReMark, but after that it gets more ambiguous.

Would it be safe to assume Legend of Everfree is between seasons 6 and 7, then the Dance/Movie/Mirror Magic specials happen at various points in season 7, Forgotten Friendship and Rollercoaster of Friendship either being in late season 7 or even between seasons 7 and 8 (and maybe before the 2017 movie), Spring Breakdown in early season 8 (after the 2017 movie, before Spike gains wings in Molt Down), and Sunset's Backstage Pass and Holidays Unwrapped being during season 9? With the possibility that will be when those specials/movies will be released in this version or is that something that hasn't quite been sorted out for you yet?

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7939684
We haven’t sorted that out yet.

Does Anon-a-Miss happen? I hope not, but am curious.

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7939773
No. It doesn’t happen.

7939786
I had a feeling, but was curious, thanks!

So, did Pony Sunset ever have a sushi waitress job like she was shown to have in canon? Or did she avoid that job due to the fish (granted dunno if she'd be as uneasy with seafood the same way she would be with beef and other types of meat)?

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7940058
She didn’t have a sushi waitress job. She didn’t eat any type of meat.

Okay, a few things:

First, what would be the name of Wallflower Blush's human counterpart?

Second, some possible stuff for the Girls (and Spike) in their adult lives:

Susan could become the new Principal of Canterlot High after Celestia's Human Counterpart gets promoted to Superintendent and Luna's human counterpart goes to back up her sister.

Tara becomes the new science teacher at Canterlot High (with multiple PhDs at that). Of course, there ARE accusations that she only got the job because she's the new Principal's girlfriend, but she does MORE THAN good enough at the job to prove she has plenty of skill to handle it and shut up at least most of the ones that accused her of getting the job because of favoritism.

Spike, meanwhile, is INCREDIBLY healthy for a dog that is more than twenty human years old, often proving to have far greater strength, speed, agility, durability, stamina, eyesight, hearing and smell than most much larger young adult dogs (well, the latter when it's just him, Tara, Susan and their closest friends at any rate - he is pretty careful to put on a good acting job when somebody who ISN'T already in the know is around). And, yes, a big part of that IS the fact he has been gaining more and more of a dragon's longevity as he gets older.

Roxanne is, naturally, a professional athlete (being careful to hold back enough to not reveal her powers in public, yet showing enough skill where she doesn't NEED her powers anyway) who dabbles in music as a hobby.

Fauna is, naturally, a veterinarian (and the only one Tara takes Spike to for his annual check-ups as she IS in the know about the magic stuff).

Pinkie is a professional caterer (combines party planning with preparing LOTS of food)

Asheleigh, of course, works on the family farm (with a side job related to selling fruit)

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7958022
First, I hadn’t thought of a name for human Wallflower Blush.

Second, those aren’t bad ideas.

7958034
Thanks very much.

As for a real name for Human Wallflower Blush - maybe Willow Blythe.

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7958065
I’ll consider that.

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7958065
Blake suggested Waverly Bloomfield.

7958960
Yeah. That sounds like that could be a good one too.

Given this version will be bringing up the human Sunset Shimmer, will the whereabouts on the original human counterparts of the Dazzlings be addressed too in this version? Did they have human counterparts to begin with?

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7976150
I don’t think they had human counterparts.

7976178
Neither did Sunset in canon (at least, if she did, that counterpart never showed up), but she does here.

And Sombra, Chrysalis and Tirek didn't have human world counterparts that showed up canonically either, but that doesn't stop fans from making their own.


7976150
That is an extremely good question. There are several theories, but they ARE only theories.

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7977607
I’m not sure how to incorporate human counterparts for the Dazzlings.

7977614
Maybe you don't have to. It could be as simple as the Dazzlings killing and replacing their human counterparts "off-screen" and be left at that.

Perhaps the Human Dazzlings were a small-name band that Adagio decided to use as a cover and she killed the human Dazzlings to make sure they didn't blow her and her "sisters'" covers.

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

So, did human Sunset know the human versions of Rainbow Dash, Applejack, Rarity, Fluttershy, and Pinkie before her parents were killed (aka the catalyst that led to her becoming a mean bully)? Or did she attend a different school from them and not meet them until high school?

BlueBioWolf
Group Admin

7981617
Different school.

  • Viewing 51 - 100 of 76