These stories seem good so far, but I always need to read a story twice before I can be certain of its quality.

Wasn't impressed with this story but the author shows great potential!

These are the best of the best, and I recommend them to everypony!

These stories would be among my all-time favorites if it weren't for that terrible, terrible ending. Sometimes an author feels trapped by their story as it grows into a monster, but there were easy alterations that could have been made to these stories to point the characters towards a happier ending.

These are in my top 50 stories of all time.

These stories are definitely worthy of rereading. They're in my top 100, but not the top 50..

These stories are good so far, and have great potential, but they have been abandoned. 😭

The plot is good! This story has potential. But the grammar and style is undermining it. All you need is a good editor! Otherwise, I love these stories!

This story weaves plot elements together in interesting and fascinating ways! 😍

One (or more, or all) characters in this story are really well-written and interesting.

This story is off to a great start and I'm super excited to see where it goes! I really hope the author decides to revisit it. 🥺