Mystery
Founded by Arcict · Report

Pony Mysteries

Cakes on a train? Mysterious masked mare making trouble? Runaway adventure book before you could finish it? Minor crimes and/or silly crimes more fitting Equestria or otherwise something you could actually find in the cartoon should go here.

Order: Date Added

E40 Years
MLP: FiM
MLP Gen 5
Adventure
Mystery
A community collaboration of a tale that spawns across all generations of My Little Pony.
Alt. Universe
Crossover
Main 6
Grogar
Mane 5
bookhorse125 · 41k words · 72 3 · 1.4k views
E"Where Has Everypony Gone?!"
MLP: FiM
Comedy
Mystery
The day after her coronation in Canterlot, Twilight wakes up to discover everyone has just... vanished. Finding out what happened to them may be the most difficult thing she's ever done...
Twilight
deadpansnarker · 3.4k words · 107 7 · 1.7k views
TDaring Do: Shadows Over Equestria
MLP: FiM
Adventure
Horror
Mystery

Narcotics
Gore
Violence
Death
Profanity
Alt. Universe
Twilight
Zecora
OC
Daring Do
Luster Dawn
PonyJosiah13 · 67k words · 44 3 · 605 views
EThe Train Ride
MLP: FiM
Mystery
Slice of Life
Herman always thought that ponies were an exceedingly friendly bunch, and he figured it was in their nature to be kind and open to all strangers—even to those of different races. But what if he was wrong? What if there was another explanation?
Human
OC
Royal Guard
Snuffy · 50k words · 1,013 29 · 14k views
TPonyville Noire: Rising Nightmares
MLP: FiM
Adventure
Horror
Mystery
A masked assassin. A thieving archeologist. An ancient evil stirring beneath Ponyville. And the only things standing in their way are Daring Do and Phillip Finder.
Gore
Sex
Narcotics
Violence
Death
Profanity
Alt. Universe
Twilight
OC
Other
Daring Do
Flash Sentry
PonyJosiah13 · 207k words · 61 1 · 799 views
EGoing with the Grain
MLP: FiM
Adventure
Mystery
Slice of Life
Applejack finds out there may be another branch of her family in Whinnieapolis on the other side of Equestria, so she sets off on the longest journey of her life to find out.
Applejack
OC
Bronyxy · 15k words · 10 1 · 255 views
TPonyville Noire: Misty Streets of Equestria
MLP: FiM
Romance
Adventure
Mystery
Scarred from their final encounter with Zugzwang, Phillip Finder and Daring Do struggle to make peace with the past while balancing a slew of new mysteries that will take them beyond Ponyville.
Gore
Sex
Narcotics
Violence
Death
Profanity
Alt. Universe
Twilight
OC
Other
Daring Do
Flash Sentry
PonyJosiah13 · 190k words · 87 3 · 1.2k views
EDaring Do: The Opera
MLP: FiM
Mystery
Slice of Life
Diamond Tiara is excited to have a starring role in Autumn Blaze's new opera. She knows the Opera House isn't haunted, but if it were, she'd be ready to give any Opera Spirit a stern talking-to.
Diamond Tiara
CMCs
Autumn Blaze
AlexTFish · 10k words · 76 1 · 1k views
TPonyville Noire: Kriegspiel—Black, White, and Scarlet
MLP: FiM
Romance
Horror
Mystery
War has come to Ponyville. As a criminal mastermind, a cruel pirate, and a mare with mysterious motives fight for control, Daring Do and Phillip Finder are put to the test with new cases and new foes.
Gore
Sex
Narcotics
Violence
Death
Profanity
Alt. Universe
Twilight
OC
Other
Daring Do
Flash Sentry
PonyJosiah13 · 282k words · 121 8 · 2k views
EShowdown at the Card Table
MLP: FiM
Drama
Mystery
Thriller
Two adversaries, locked in an epic clash of wills over a game of cards. Special Agent Sweetie Drops had been drawn in to this game and the importance of victory could not be overstated, but there was only going to be one winner ...
Bon-Bon
Bronyxy · 1k words · 17 1 · 507 views
EAll That Glitters
MLP: FiM
Adventure
Drama
Mystery
The Mane Six all felt drawn to the Mirror Pool where they witness the arrival of a pair of glamorous silver and gold alicorns. They soon show they are not as beautiful as they seem, but why did they come to Ponyville and where are Celestia and Luna?
Twilight
Rainbow Dash
Rarity
OC
Main 6
Bronyxy · 7.5k words · 9 1 · 410 views
TPonyville Noire: Tails of Two Private Eyes
MLP: FiM
Romance
Adventure
Mystery
Daring Do is a thief trying for a second chance. Phillip Finder is a private detective with no scruples. Ponyville is a city embroiled in corruption with war on the horizon. They may be the only hope for law and order left.
Gore
Sex
Narcotics
Violence
Death
Profanity
Alt. Universe
Twilight
OC
Other
Daring Do
Flash Sentry
PonyJosiah13 · 261k words · 245 10 · 5k views
EBeyond the Veil
MLP: FiM
Dark
Adventure
Mystery
Rainbow Dash is trapped in an alternate dimension.
Alt. Universe
Twilight
Rainbow Dash
Apple Bloom
Other
Main 6
Twi-Fi · 7.1k words · 25 1 · 851 views

Pony Mysteries

Stats

FIMFiction

Follow & Support Us