Fluttershy has something she regrets deeply, something that causes her nightmares, driving her to take even more care of her critters. Her secret is one that no one would expect from her...
A young hippogriff student begins attending the School of Friendship. Her roommate is annoying, she can't stop thinking of home, and horrors hidden in the dark are beginning to reveal themselves.
W-what," Pinkie swallowed nervously as she tried to speak, finding her throat was suddenly very dry. "Are you?" It seemed to stare at her for a few seconds, its dark eye sockets peering directly into her soul. "Death."
The effects of the spell that rebounded on Fluttershy were never fixed, leaving her trapped in the body of a monster known as Flutterbat. The pony once known as Fluttershy is presumed dead.
The Mane Six are joined by three others in a quest to use the Elements of Harmony one last time, as a brewing war between Tartarus and the free creatures of the world threatens to destroy Equestria forever.
Fluttershy had disappeared from a strange mist that covered most of Equestria for weeks. She, after being out in the mist for so long seemed to wandered off to the Everfree forest and in a strange side effect had lost her memory. Only to find a leaf.
After staying away from her friends for years, Fluttershy is stunned to discover Rainbow Dash on her doorstep looking haggard and asking for sanctuary in her escape from someone she won't name.
Fluttershy buys a new painting for her home. It's a cute little country scene, and it fascinates her and fills her with longing for an idyllic life. But there's more to it than she can see at first glance.