• Published 16th Sep 2014
  • 297 Views, 17 Comments

Effigy of Anarchy - SaltyJustice



Cloudchaser's sister has disappeared in Trottingham, and the Guard won't even lift a hoof to help her. Desperate, she calls upon an old acquaintance, and is pulled into something far larger than a simple disappearance.

Comments ( 8 )

Thank you for the story ! :twilightsmile:
Awesome characters and storyline :pinkiehappy:
Is there a chance that we meet Silent and Cloudchaser again in future stories ? :rainbowderp: The ending looks like start of series :twilightsheepish:

5095435
It's not the start of a series, but I wouldn't rule out seeing these two again at some point.

Generally, when I write a story, I think of it as being done when the story ends. Unless a sequel was planned from the beginning, I think sequels usually degrade the events of the first story and cheapen the characters. After all, if the hero went through a growth arc in the first story, how are they going to do it again in the second one? It's not impossible, but it requires a plan.

That said, there was a lot in this story that wound up getting cut, and I had other plans to tie this together with a longer-running metaplot. Our heroes may yet return as part of something bigger.

5096698
I was left with slight "not quite closed" feeling.
I think I was subconsciously expecting some kind of epilogue which would close questions left (there are a lot of these: How were Flitter and other victims doing after it, what happened to sons of Equestria organization, how did the princess take news about the case (I suppose Cloudchaser told her everything), how did these events affect Cloudchaser's life, did princess clear her and Silent from charges etc), such thing is quite frequent in detective genre - hence my reaction. I thought these questions were left unanswered deliberately to have easy start for the next story and the next case.
(BTW what are answers to these questions (if you have time to answer one or two) - I'm really curious? :twilightblush:)

Anyway, thank you for the story again! it was quite a ride :twilightsmile:
I will be really happy to meet them again when and if you have inspiration for it :twilightsmile:

5097080


THAR BE SPOILERS BELOW THIS POINT. AVAST.
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv





Just a friendly heads up for any new readers whose eyes hit the comments section.

I'll answer the questions in a PM when I'm less busy than I usually am.

5097507
oops! :twilightblush:
edited my message and hid questions under white font.

Brought here by Paul's review. The lack of a proper denouement is a bit disappointing, given all the unanswered questions, but it was still a compelling story.

5096698
Like others, I came here thanks to a review, and I'm glad I did.

Now, as to the idea of a series or sequel, the formula here lends itself well to that. Silent River did say that 'chaser is an advisor, and she has others, so that opens the door to any number of stories showing the adventures of Silent River, and introducing new advisors or revisiting existing ones. I think the only real limit really is your imagination, and I for one would like to see what you come up with.

Login or register to comment