Pinkie's friends have all been convinced all her thoughts revolve around are purely fun. And naturally, most of them do. Even Pinkie herself has been convinced she is nothing more than a clown, made to make people laugh. Sometimes this makes her happy, but other times... A feeling... Somewhere deep... Is hidden. But as soon as Caramel comes along, everything changes. He may be able to prove just how intelligent a special somepony is.
Proofread by BluegrassBrooke.
If someone could draw me some fanart of PinkieXCaramel, it'd be highly appreciated!... It's so hard to find...
Edit: I added a new chapter at the beginning and changed some dialogue in a few chapters. Unfortunately, with the addition of the Prologue, most of the comments are offset a chapter. So now, a lot of the comments don't make too much sense. My apologies.
Well that was depressing, but im still interseted to see where this goes. I will await your next chapter good arthur.
Aww I feel so bad for Pinkie. But Caramel is on the case right?
This story has some real momentum going now your doing great keep it up
Please Contuine
What the hell happened to Twilight? I hope she gets better
4286427 I agree.
UPDATE!!!
Yay they made up.
Awww... so adorable. Why's Pinkie so heavy though? Is that some sort of foreshadowing? Is her sadness weighing her down or something?
That is very touching.
I thought you would never updated. I'm glad you did. Update Soon!:-)
What will Caramel do Press the issue or turn and leave? Will Pinke admit her true feeling to him or continue push away what may be the one pony willing to care? Stay tuned for the next chapter of Who'd Have Guessed!
Great chapter really builds the anticipation for whats to come you put the cliff hanger in just the right place.
I like this style.
What happened!?!
oh im so excited for this development but whats up with Mac
4507024 The fire happened.
Interesting development. I hope she gets better soon.
Where'd the new chapters go?
4557445 Sorry about that. I was working on them today on my iPad and I pressed the "publish" button instead of the "edit" button. My bad
4557903 Oh, okay.
4558026 here, because you seem so excited, I finished one of the chapters I was working on.
AJ was just an illusion?
4655688 Only time will tell when AJ gets her own chapter.
4655928 NOOOOOOI WANT TO FIND OUT NOW!!!
4656846 I CAN ONLY WRITE QUALITY SO FAST
4656895 F-fine...
4656993 O-Oh, please don't cry...! I'm sorry...
4657094 It's okay... But how long do you think it'll take?
4660855 Maybe half a week. I'm already 700 hundred words into the next chapter. It may depend on if I decide to make the chapter I'm working on already come at a later time.
4660976 Alrighty then! Can't wait!!
Yayy! I didn't get the notification though.
4705393
That's because I goofed and published it a while back. If you look it says June 16th, even though I published it a few weeks after that.
4719920 I'm on the mobile site, so it doesn't show the posting date for individual chapters.
4720120 ooh, okay.
*Returns it at the red box*
Aw pinks
Let me get one of those brownies...
4896938
*travels inter-dimensionally and gives you one through your now-magical computer screen that can materialize objects*
Oh ponyvil, these ponies are crazy.
Hmmm , black coffee
Howdy cuz
Daww
Here we are at the cross roads!
Time to pick a sign
What a nice journal.
He knows to much!
Event flags every where?!?
Lend that helping hoof.
Block has been used!
4897007
Well now my computer screen is a death trap and a thing of Dreams.
I will enjoy this Brownie of Holy power.
Pinkie,
Only you! Can prevent forest fires.
Whaaaa